Welcome to Nicola's Italian Restaurant And Catering
Nicola's Italian Restaurant And Catering, located in Cold Spring, NY, is a quintessential Italian dining experience that embodies the warmth and authenticity of Italian-American cuisine. With a menu featuring hearty dishes like Clams Casino, Shrimp Marinara, and generous Wedges, patrons rave about the flavorful and well-portioned meals. The inviting atmosphere, coupled with attentive service, creates a memorable dining experience, as reflected in glowing customer reviews. From classic garlic knots to the delightful presence of the owner engaging with guests, Nicola's captures the essence of family-oriented dining. For anyone seeking genuine Italian comfort food, this restaurant is a must-visit.
-
3620 US-9, Cold Spring, NY 10516, United States3620 US-9, Cold Spring, NY 10516, United States Hotline: +1 845-809-5637
If you find yourself in Cold Spring, NY, Nicola's Italian Restaurant and Catering is a gem not to be missed. Nestled conveniently at 3620 US-9, this restaurant melds traditional Italian-American flavors with a warm, inviting atmosphere. A phone call at +1 845-809-5637 is all it takes to book your table.
At Nicola's, dining is not just about food; it’s about a joyous experience steeped in authenticity. The menu boasts a variety of appetizers, like the Scungilli Salad for $22.50 and the hearty Hot Antipasto, complete with stuffed tomatoes and clam casino, at $18.75. Don't overlook the delectable Fried Mozzarella Sticks for $13.75 and the comforting Garlic Bread with Cheese for just $6.25, which are sure to set the stage for a satisfying meal.
The poultry offerings are equally enticing. Try the Chicken Francese, featuring boneless chicken breast tenderly sautéed in a buttery lemon wine sauce for $24.95. Or enjoy the classic Chicken Parmigiana, richly covered in parmesan, also priced at $24.95. Each dish exemplifies hearty, well-portioned, and flavor-rich Italian cooking that brings comfort to the table.
As for the entrees, the undeniable stars are the meat selections, including the Broiled Sirloin Steak for $37.50 and the succulent Veal Cutlet Parmigiana, at $32.50. Each dish is executed perfectly, showcasing the restaurant's commitment to quality and tradition. Diners rave about the generous portions and the homey feel, with mentions of robust flavors that remind one of cherished family gatherings.
Customer reviews reflect a consistent theme: warmth of service and satisfaction with quality meals. Will Livingston praises Nicola's as “classic as an Italian restaurant can be,” highlighting the no-frills yet hearty dishes that capture the essence of Italian-American dining. Carmen Tookmanian shares a sentiment echoed by many, appreciating the “hot, fresh, and delicious” food that arrives swiftly from the kitchen, thanks to attentive servers.
On a busy Saturday night, Zai Franco enjoyed the bustling atmosphere and impeccable attention from the staff, reaffirming that Nicola's remains a preferred dining spot. Ian Y. Lo, who visited on Mother’s Day, couldn't help but mention the incredible sole Francese and “grandma pizza” that left him eager for a return visit.
The personal touch from the owner adds to the charm. Margaret Steinmeyer found her experience elevated by the friendly hospitality, with the owner personally visiting tables to ensure satisfaction—a warm welcome that makes you feel like family.
To sum it up, Nicola's Italian Restaurant and Catering isn’t just about great food; it’s about creating joyful memories in a cozy nook of Cold Spring. It's a culinary journey inviting everyone to savor authentic flavors, generous portions, and heartfelt service in a setting that feels just like home.
Nicola’s is as classic as an Italian restaurant can be. The service is awesome and the food is no frills, hearty, well portioned and flavorful. This was my first time dining here but Nicolas came highly recommended. The atmosphere is warm and quaint, the bread was plentiful, and the entree portions were generous. (I was the only member of the clean plate club in my 5 person party). The price is right, the energy is wonderful, and the food is classic Italian American. This place is no BS - served with a soup or house salad on the side. This experience was complete with classic plastic PepsiCola cups and garlic knots even your Nonna would love. I will be returning the first chance I get.
My husband and I went to Nicola’s Italian restaurant today. We were extremely happy with the quality of the food, right out of the kitchen, hot, fresh and delicious. Our servers were very friendly and attentive.Overall we highly recommend this place.
Stopped by on a Saturday night and this place was fairly busy. We sat on an available high top near the bar. Our waiter was very attentive & the food was absolutely amazing. Recommend if you are in the area!
I was just here for Mother’s Day yesterday. It was also my first time coming to this place. I got to say, the food was good and service was excellent for a busy weekend. We ordered the sole francese and grandma pizza which were phenomenal. I’ll definitely be back again soon.
Super friendly. The owner, a lovely little woman, went to each table. Food was exc3llent. 2ill go again for sure and will bring friends.
The food was delicious and every dish we had!! We had a beautiful time! Great food great place great staff!!! Thankyou
We've eaten here several times, but most notably for our daughter's communion and recently for her confirmation dinner celebration with family. The food is amazing, the staff is so kind and attentive (they really do make you feel like family), and they are great with large groups as well as just a dinner for two. I can't thank them enough for being wonderful hosts and making wonderful memories for my family and I! All of the dishes we've tried (between extended family there's quite a variety of palates) have been very tasty and huge portions, so there's plenty to box up and take home for leftovers!
We got take out. The food was very good and flavorful